Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 11:34 am  

B0NES wrote:

You wouldn't need Westerman if Tickle and Fitz stay.

good idea fitz can play for another year, westerman a week

Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 11:38 am  

Sheldon wrote:

IMO washy should leave for his own career

Or the club could realise that they don't need Westerman when they've got Washy.

Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 11:40 am  

east hull FC fan wrote:

Or the club could realise that they don't need Westerman when they've got Washy.

different type of players and styles.

Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 11:41 am  

Sheldon wrote:

different type of players and styles.

Really?

Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 11:51 am  

Same types of player for me. But Westermans a better attacker imo.

Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 1:26 pm  

east hull FC fan wrote:

Think i should explain that last part better.


I think we could get Owen and Murphy with Cusacks wage.
Radfords wage goes to LMS and a bit of it to Westerman.
Dowes Would top up Westermans (maybe with some left over).
Shenton Could take the money it cost to release Raynor and King with anything left of Dowes wage also.

But this would leave us with only 3 props! Unless Lauaki moves there next year.

Also with Murphy and Owen signing we wouldn't need Calderwood so we could get 2 young props with his wage? Watts and A N Other(not sure who tbh)

Cusack is one very little, you'd be surprised tbh. His wages would not cover the two players you mentioned.

Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 1:30 pm  

Sheldon wrote:

what if we could get westerman and barba?

I'm only playing the advocate here btw.

Imo we need the following players:-

Replacement for Calderwood (unless he stays): Owen/Murphy/An Other
Replacement for Cusack: LMS/An Other
Replacement for Tickle (if he leaves): Westerman/An Other
Replacement for Washbrook (if he leaves): ??

I think Hall, Whiting, Manu and Fitz will all stay.

Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 1:51 pm  

PAUL M wrote:

Imo we need the following players:-

Replacement for Calderwood (unless he stays): Owen/Murphy/An Other
Replacement for Cusack: LMS/An Other
Replacement for Tickle (if he leaves): Westerman/An Other
Replacement for Washbrook (if he leaves): ??

I think Hall, Whiting, Manu and Fitz will all stay.

I think Tickle will stay..

Not bothered if Hall goes, unless I see a massive improvement in his defence tbh.

Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 5:22 pm  

berrigans bitch wrote:

I think Tickle will stay..

Not bothered if Hall goes, unless I see a massive improvement in his defence tbh.

He wont be going,and as for tickle i think agar will be pulling out all the stops to keep him,plus manu,plus fitz,infact i reckon talks will already be taking place,oh yeh and whiting will be staying now hes proved his fitness after his 2 terrible injuries,plus the great form hes showing.

all these are just my opinions of course.

Re: Backs 2011 : Wed Apr 14, 2010 5:24 pm  

wolfie wrote:

He wont be going,and as for tickle i think agar will be pulling out all the stops to keep him,plus manu,plus fitz,infact i reckon talks will already be taking place,oh yeh and whiting will be staying now hes proved his fitness after his 2 terrible injuries,plus the great form hes showing.

all these are just my opinions of course.

So basically we'll be spending up to the cap on the same players we have now which everyone agrees isn't good enough?