Re: Catlans away : Thu Jul 25, 2024 1:15 pm  

tomkins will probably have a worldie and will give the rest of the team a lift irrespective of how well he plays

Re: Catlans away : Thu Jul 25, 2024 1:22 pm  

No Johnstone, Abdull or McMeekan but Fages and Tomkins back, I'd imagine Sam start off the bench like you say he won't be match fit.

Re: Catlans away : Thu Jul 25, 2024 1:43 pm  

weaver93 wrote:

100% agree.. would be in favour, giving him an extension, if can get him off the quota.

Even if he remains on quota I would be in favour of an extension. He's already here, settled and playing well. We could sign someone who can't adjust over here and turn out to be another Kane Evans perish the thought.

Re: Catlans away : Thu Jul 25, 2024 1:46 pm  

Think we might have Moy/Jebson on bench ahead of Gardiner purely in case Carlos break down. Chamberlain could slot into centre.

Walker
Martin
Sutcliffe
Carlos
Briscoe
Trueman
Charles
Sao
Smith
Ese ese
Chamberlain
Lane
Aydin

Fash
King V
Moy or Jebson
Balmforth

Re: Catlans away : Thu Jul 25, 2024 1:47 pm  

Marcus's Bicycle wrote:

Even if he remains on quota I would be in favour of an extension. He's already here, settled and playing well. We could sign someone who can't adjust over here and turn out to be another Kane Evans perish the thought.

abdul missing is a blow for us

[Chris71]

Re: Catlans away : Thu Jul 25, 2024 10:43 pm  

Hopefully with Tomkins back in the Catalans squad it gives our players a boost and bigger incentive to get one over him for his constant bagging in his punditry. Whilst some may have been justified, a lot of it has seemed more about just bagging them for the sake of it.

Re: Catlans away : Fri Jul 26, 2024 10:25 am  

Dave K. wrote:

Sao has been excellent the last few weeks, seems to have improved his discipline and cut out his mistakes, I was all for getting rid, but I'd definitely keep him now.

The thing with Sao is he’s a competitor and tries so hard. When the clubs getting whacked every week and there’s no confidence he tries too hard and gets through a mountain of work hence the errors.

Put him in a decent team and suddenly he will look class

Re: Catlans away : Fri Jul 26, 2024 10:27 am  

Abdul out which gives us less to think about in their attack - 3 more assists last week vs Cas? Two from his left boot.

Surely Tomkins will score, he always seems to play well vs us.

The lads will be high on confidence. Would love to see another win, but think they might have too much in the end. Looking forward to it, which is a positive!

Re: Catlans away : Fri Jul 26, 2024 11:15 am  

Hullrealist wrote:

The thing with Sao is he’s a competitor and tries so hard. When the clubs getting whacked every week and there’s no confidence he tries too hard and gets through a mountain of work hence the errors.

Put him in a decent team and suddenly he will look class

I agree. I've never watched Sao an thought he didn't care or wasn't putting any effort in. Generally the opposite as you say. Not a 2nd rower though

Re: Catlans away : Fri Jul 26, 2024 12:38 pm  

Jake the Peg wrote:

I agree. I've never watched Sao an thought he didn't care or wasn't putting any effort in. Generally the opposite as you say. Not a 2nd rower though

I think running out wide he seems to find himself in a bit more space or in 2 on 1 tackles, rather than 3 on 1 tackles straight up the middle. This seems to make him force an offload a bit more and often he does it at the wrong times and just hands possession back. He's a very good player at just running straight and hard, and recently he's become more disciplined with his offloads and his performances have improved because of it.