: Wed May 27, 2009 11:55 am
Gordon Gekko wrote:
Whiting isn't a centre
Jesus. Not this again. Whatever you think Whiting's best position is, he is currently the best centre at the club.
Gordon Gekko wrote:
and Calderwood only see the ball from kicks.
The same would be true of any winger and will remain so until the attacking problems are sorted out.
handbrake wrote:
IMO it is not looking something like. We have shipped 3 tries in 2 games as a direct result of Whiting getting his defensive positioning/reading wrong.
No. The tries were shipped as a direct result of the defence being too compressed in the middle of the park, leaving four players for Whiting and Calderwood to cover.
trys'r'us wrote:
Although he was replaced by a one-legged player who's been out for weeks and hasn't been training at half even when he was fit. And he still created more, even if he had no pace and the timing of his passes was a bit off. Plus the game had gone and the players were visibly down, especially after the mistake from the drop-out.
Basically, I don't think we can judge the attack with Berrigan at half based on that 40 mins.
I'm not. I'm a million percent sure that Berrigan will be a better option. That said, any scrum half would struggle given the lack of forward power we currently have.
I don't knock individual players ..But this time CT should take a good look at himself ..to have a off day with your kicking game is one thing but his overall performance was shocking ..for the leeds game I would have left R Horne at F/B put Berro /T Lee at H/Bs and Danny H and M Tony at hooker ..M Tony look a little rusty and should have been played has a interchange ..But that gone now next game is Saints 
Looking forward to that one 
