Re: Shopping List 2023 : Wed Oct 19, 2022 9:51 pm  

Tomorrow is the only day without a WC game on. Ideal time to make an announcement

Re: Shopping List 2023 : Thu Oct 20, 2022 6:14 am  

Exactly this especially when fan frustration and apathy is at all time high due to the dismal stuff served up for at least the oast 4 seasons.
With the club wanting/needing membership renewals and to attract new ones then releasing your better players and not having replacements to announce at the same time is hardly going to help increase the numbers or engender positivity in the fan base, more so it increases negative thoughts and feelings.

Anyone in Hull FC's marketing should understand the fans' anxiety over the Connor replacement situation. It breeds an air of apathy and some hostility , as if the Club doesn't care about its fans and has an arrogance about them that they will do things in their time, despite the anxiety it causes. Even if we cannot name the replacement, at least officially comment on how far on negotiations are, rather than leaving it to the HDM. If they want to retain and expand their paying membership schemes, to be silent on this issue has probably had the reverse effect, with people waiting and keeping their diminishing free cash spare for other things. I know the Club doesn't actually operate with that intention, but it does feel like the gap between fans and the management is as wide as ever because of this. Fans do have a right to be impatient, why not? They have as much right to be that way as those who choose not to be, and the number that are suggests that something is triggering this. Time for someone to spread calm rather than panic. FWIW, Smith I believe will have his plan in place, and I don't think for one minute it will include a Reynolds type of panic buy, but it'd be beneficial for someone from within to confirm this, officially.

Re: Shopping List 2023 : Thu Oct 20, 2022 10:58 am  

I really hope Smith improves the way we handle recruitment and retention other ubs announce things much quicker and are much more proactive with retentions like Saints, getting their better players to sign on well I'm advance of their contracts running out, I know we have at times given out long contracts early, but we should be looking at extending the likes of Brown and Satae now rather than waiting until layer in the year.

Re: Shopping List 2023 : Thu Oct 20, 2022 11:03 am  

They cannot comment on ongoing negotiaitons, that is ridiculous. Who does that?

If any supporter is feeling anxious or hostile about a lack of news then they need to get a grip, FFS.

Re: Shopping List 2023 : Thu Oct 20, 2022 11:14 am  

ComeOnYouUll wrote:

They cannot comment on ongoing negotiaitons, that is ridiculous. Who does that?

If any supporter is feeling anxious or hostile about a lack of news then they need to get a grip, FFS.

But it shouldn't have cone to this, the deal should have been complete before we announced Connor going, as supporters losing our best player for free that's the least we deserve and know our main signing depends on other teams releasing players, just wait two weeks announce Connor leaving with his replacement signed.

After the last few years and our generally poor recruitment I think that's the least we can expect.

Im sure it will work out, but I don't think we have handled the Connor leaving very well at all.

Re: Shopping List 2023 : Thu Oct 20, 2022 11:23 am  

On another note, looks like Shaul will be here next season, as no one wants him. Giving him a new 3 year deal in 2020 after his injury is nearly as bad as signing Reynolds.

Re: Shopping List 2023 : Thu Oct 20, 2022 11:41 am  

ComeOnYouUll wrote:

They cannot comment on ongoing negotiaitons, that is ridiculous. Who does that?

If any supporter is feeling anxious or hostile about a lack of news then they need to get a grip, FFS.

Of course they can, without naming names "negotiations with a replacement half are ongoing" etc. You get a grip, people are anxious, we were rubbish with our best player in the team, he's gone, no comment from the Club, purported to be in negotiation with Jake Clifford, all hinging on Luke Brooks leaving Wests. Anxiety among fans is understandable, given that with Jake we were ninth and awful, and he alone probably kept us from relegation, so lets all be jolly calm now he's gone. Ho hum!

Re: Shopping List 2023 : Thu Oct 20, 2022 12:08 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

On another note, looks like Shaul will be here next season, as no one wants him. Giving him a new 3 year deal in 2020 after his injury is nearly as bad as signing Reynolds.

Strange one that Dave Wakey were really keen on keeping him at the end of last season and they are certainly light on players I wondered if they were gong for Walker but obviously not. I sincerely hope we aren't hanging out for a fee. For if Jake doesn't warrant one then Shaul certainly doesn't. We need that cap space to beef up the forwards. Perhaps Wakey were not offering enough against what he is getting or maybe he is due a Benefit soon and thinks he'd be better placed doing that at the FC. perhaps Trim have signed Hardacker. whatever the reasons he's certainly surplus to requirements with our current in coming players.

Re: Shopping List 2023 : Thu Oct 20, 2022 12:14 pm  

The Dentist Wilf wrote:

Strange one that Dave Wakey were really keen on keeping him at the end of last season and they are certainly light on players I wondered if they were gong for Walker but obviously not. I sincerely hope we aren't hanging out for a fee. For if Jake doesn't warrant one then Shaul certainly doesn't. We need that cap space to beef up the forwards.

New coach probably stopped the deal, not really surprised as think they already have a better fullback than Shaul at Wakey in Jowitt. Can't see him getting a SL contract now and our only chance would be to release him to a championship club with us paying most of his salary.

I suppose like others he gets a fresh start, can Smith do what no other coach has managed and get Shauls passing and decision making up to the level of other top fullbacks.

Re: Shopping List 2023 : Thu Oct 20, 2022 12:26 pm  

Sounded like Shaul and Hodgson really didn't see eye to eye, in Shauls defence he wasn't the only one. He is a decent player to fall back on should injuries hit. Hopefully a new lease of life under a new coach etc.