[Chris71]

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 1:54 pm  

mwindass wrote:

Ellam wrote:

Fash in clear, Wynne two games so i'm guess Mitch for Wynne

What did Wynne get done for? Can't say I noticed anything

Can only think its for the light push on Coote after he'd passed the ball and went down like he'd been shot which Wynne got penalised for. So if it was for that then penalty was fair enough but a ban for it is just ridiculous when Gale was hit late all game and Kleinhorsts high shot that he didn't miss with which was very much direct contact to the head and a couple of hits by Sims that looked dubious to say the least as more like shoulder charges.

But why is anybody surprised with the Disciplinary outcomes as they are literally a joke

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 2:02 pm  

Thetalentboy wrote:

That is all it is beating a bang average super league nobody who have had about 2 decent seasons in 15 !

Means nothing if we don't back it up against Wigan

Leeds have got toulouse to could be back to 2 points if we don't win

Sims and longstaff look good longstaff reminds me of Liam Farrell

Walker did well but he's deffo not better than shaul at his best hence why he can't get in a mediocre leeds side

Problem is when was Shaul last at his best

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 2:24 pm  

The Hollywood Frasier wrote:

What do you mean by back it up?

Well play like we did against Wigan about 7 or 8 rounds ago!

[Chris71]

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 2:26 pm  

Rocknrolla69er wrote:

Thetalentboy wrote:

That is all it is beating a bang average super league nobody who have had about 2 decent seasons in 15 !

Means nothing if we don't back it up against Wigan

Leeds have got toulouse to could be back to 2 points if we don't win

Sims and longstaff look good longstaff reminds me of Liam Farrell

Walker did well but he's deffo not better than shaul at his best hence why he can't get in a mediocre leeds side

Problem is when was Shaul last at his best

I'd say pre 2019 if I'm being honest and he's certainly a long way off the player he was 4 years ago after his ACL injury.

Walker for a player that has been out a side looked so assured yesterday and his though process seems to be far quicker and in just that game alone he has shown more than Shaul has all season. Unfortunately time moves on and Shaul's better days are behind him and he's not the only one.

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 2:30 pm  

Chris71 wrote:

I'd say pre 2019 if I'm being honest and he's certainly a long way off the player he was 4 years ago after his ACL injury.

Walker for a player that has been out a side looked so assured yesterday and his though process seems to be far quicker and in just that game alone he has shown more than Shaul has all season. Unfortunately time moves on and Shaul's better days are behind him and he's not the only one.

Yeah Walker was steady but apparently hoy is a done deal from Newcastle and hoy will be first choice

Will Walker come to be a back up again ?

Sims looks class and as I said longstaff looks Liam Farrell type player would deffo keep them 2

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 2:33 pm  

Rocknrolla69er wrote:

Problem is when was Shaul last at his best

But you can say that about a few and they still walk in the team ....

Houghton ,Taylor, Gale


Yet shauls the scapegoat

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 2:38 pm  

Connor Wynne gets a 1 match ban for a late hit. No mention of Fash.

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 2:39 pm  

Thetalentboy wrote:

But you can say that about a few and they still walk in the team ....

Houghton ,Taylor, Gale


Yet shauls the scapegoat

Don't think he's a scapegoat. Just not good enough anymore.

Better players have been moved on for less in recent seasons too.

He/we as a club have stagnated after the CC wins. Ultimately things need a shake up and the old guard need moving on.

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 3:04 pm  

mwindass wrote:

Hopefully another weeks training with Longstaff/Griffin/Simm will help shore up that edge.

Understandable at times, but it was all over the place against Rovers.

We've got a free hit against Wigan on Friday for me. Bigger game is against Cas.

Take more than a weeks training to get Griffin anywhere near those new boys
He needs binning
Simm to centre and Mitch to wing

just seen that Wynne copped a 1 match ban so a reprieve i guess for Griffin

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 11, 2022 3:09 pm  

hull2524 wrote:

is Simms only on loan? have we got a chance to keep him?

yes three weeks but i guess could be extended if Saints dont need him
Real class this lad has the pace just need to work on his defence.
If we could sign him and with Connor Wynne as the other centre we would have two young very good English centres with pace backed up by Carlos and Mitch.
Now that would be progress