Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 2:37 pm  

carl_spackler wrote:

Fair enough. I agree he did look a lot more confident last night, but I still just don't think he's quite either quick or strong enough. TBH I'd probably stick with Sharp over both him and Crookes.

Sharps off back to Larndan

Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 2:57 pm  

voodooroo wrote:

22 points in a playoff game!!!!!
if thats a crap winger FFS lets have two of them

Firstly, I don't recall saying he was crap. Secondly, I said apart from his goalkicking, which contributed 14 of those points.

Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 3:45 pm  

carl_spackler wrote:

Firstly, I don't recall saying he was crap. Secondly, I said apart from his goalkicking, which contributed 14 of those points.

Thirdly, sorry didnt mean it to look like you had said that and miss placed my post soz mate!!
however i think the kid has done a good job and personally would like to see him stay , but its unlikely
i did read somewhere that PG has massive regard for him and the way he goes about his business at the club mind, and seems very popular amongst the squad.

Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 4:06 pm  

voodooroo wrote:

Thirdly, sorry didnt mean it to look like you had said that and miss placed my post soz mate!!
however i think the kid has done a good job and personally would like to see him stay , but its unlikely
i did read somewhere that PG has massive regard for him and the way he goes about his business at the club mind, and seems very popular amongst the squad.

He seems a good professional and plays with enthusiasm. I'm not trying to knock the kid, I'm just not convinced he's a top 4 quality winger. If he wasn't a goalkicker I have doubts we'd have brought in him in particular.

Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 4:08 pm  

carl_spackler wrote:

He seems a good professional and plays with enthusiasm. I'm not trying to knock the kid, I'm just not convinced he's a top 4 quality winger. If he wasn't a goalkicker I have doubts we'd have brought in him in particular.

100% agree with that mate.

[Kosh]

Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 4:12 pm  

A unknown superstar wrote:

He isn't amongst the top 4 halves in the league AP stated we would be signing 2 from the 4.

I don't think he did. As I remember it he said we had 4 half back targets and would definitely sign 2 of them.

Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 4:18 pm  

Kosh wrote:

I don't think he did. As I remember it he said we had 4 half back targets and would definitely sign 2 of them.

Thats how things get lost in translation

Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 4:19 pm  

carl_spackler wrote:

He seems a good professional and plays with enthusiasm. I'm not trying to knock the kid, I'm just not convinced he's a top 4 quality winger. If he wasn't a goalkicker I have doubts we'd have brought in him in particular.

And Crookes is?

Can't really comment on Crookes as I've not seen much of him, seen Foster loads more and I like him.

Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 4:20 pm  

Tongan Mafia wrote:

If we dont get Chase id go and get Dobson

+1

i would like to see this happen

Re: More rumours... : Mon Sep 17, 2012 4:23 pm  

carl_spackler wrote:

He seems a good professional and plays with enthusiasm. I'm not trying to knock the kid, I'm just not convinced he's a top 4 quality winger. If he wasn't a goalkicker I have doubts we'd have brought in him in particular.

But the fact is he turns a lot of trys into 6 pointers and as such he becomes very important
and to be fair to the kid he is a decent winger too and certainly not afraid to do his fair share of graft IMO