Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 8:33 pm  

Woods1969 wrote:

I actually think if Hodgson did drop those 4 and put the young lads in and we did get beat most fans would accept the defeat because I know they would give 100%

Hopefully although for example yesterday we has someone on here call Hookem "championship level at best".

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 8:38 pm  

Thetalentboy wrote:

How is mcintosh avoiding people's backlash ?

Handley scored 5 trys past him and he's makes a lot of errors

Yet people always pick him

He didn't and you would know that if you attended the game.

[Chris71]

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 8:43 pm  

Thetalentboy wrote:

How is mcintosh avoiding people's backlash ?

Handley scored 5 trys past him and he's makes a lot of errors

Yet people always pick him

He’s probably avoided backlash as you say compared to others but I wouldn’t say he’s avoiding criticism as he is hit and miss and still has to prove himself but he hasn’t been as woeful as the old stagers who have form for poor performances.

He looks shaky confidence wise currently but there is no leader on the field or seemingly in the playing group.

While Handley scored 5 tries they weren’t all past or down to McIntosh

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 8:44 pm  

Sao is a big blow, not bothered about the other two. Evans is ok, but not worst a quota spot IMO.

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 9:34 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

He didn't and you would know that if you attended the game.

Come off it defensively he's awful

Drops a fair few bombs aswell

The interception is masking peoples view

Cause he's been underwhelming upto now

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 9:55 pm  

Woods1969 wrote:

I actually think if Hodgson did drop those 4 and put the young lads in and we did get beat most fans would accept the defeat because I know they would give 100%

It wont happen but i agree with you.Most fans would accept effort even in defeat.
To be honest the two clubs should play as many younger players as possible and stick two fingers up to the RFL for giving us the last game on Sunday

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 10:00 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

Sao is a big blow, not bothered about the other two. Evans is ok, but not worst a quota spot IMO.

So if we now accept Evans is poor,McIntosh pretty average then apart from Lovodua it highlights Just how bad Hodgsons recruitment has been.
Question is do we really want him to head the recruitment for next season

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 10:09 pm  

bonaire wrote:

It wont happen but i agree with you.Most fans would accept effort even in defeat.
To be honest the two clubs should play as many younger players as possible and stick two fingers up to the RFL for giving us the last game on Sunday

The effort myth is nonsense

Sport is about winning end of

A team loses 5 or 6 on the bounce there getting stick no matter about the "effort"

This is professional sport not under 6 sports day

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 10:10 pm  

bonaire wrote:

So if we now accept Evans is poor,McIntosh pretty average then apart from Lovodua it highlights Just how bad Hodgsons recruitment has been.
Question is do we really want him to head the recruitment for next season

He's operated on a shoe string since he's got here.
He should get a shot to try and mould his team.

Re: HULL KR MAGIC WEEKEND : Mon Jul 04, 2022 10:32 pm  

mwindass wrote:

He's operated on a shoe string since he's got here.
He should get a shot to try and mould his team.

Thats rubbish
Reynolds the most expensive overseas signing we have made
Evans when he plays, wont be cheap extremely average
Gale hopefully short term but a failure and probably on a good wage
McIntosh again wont be cheap thought he had potential but looking like a very average S/L player
Lovodua by far the best of the bunch

how many shots do you give him?