Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 6:58 pm  

*1865* wrote:

Not sure, played in the centres this weekend I think. Wouldn't mind him & Logan in the centres, two very different types.

I think ours backs will be

Shaul
Lancaster
Talanoa
Carlos (can't yet spell his second name)
Fonua

Naughton
Logan

Not quite as good as the backline I expected, but has some potential there and certainly looks better on paper than this years.

I still see no need for Michael, particularly when we have Yeaman who could cover centre and move Talanoa to the wing.

Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:04 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

I think ours backs will be

Shaul
Lancaster
Talanoa
Carlos (can't yet spell his second name)
Fonua

Naughton
Logan

Not quite as good as the backline I expected, but has some potential there and certainly looks better on paper than this years.

I still see no need for Michael, particularly when we have Yeaman who could cover centre and move Talanoa to the wing.

I'd be disappointed with Talanoa at centre, think his strengths are better suited to the wing.

Shaul
Lancaster
Fonua
Logan
Talanoa

Naughton
Tuimavave

That's based on what we've supposedly signed.

Quite a difference from the back 5 i'd hoped for -

Shaul
Lancaster
Inu
Logan
Vidot

Naughton
Talanoa

I too don't see the need to retain Micheals, but Yeaman does see himself playing in the pack, so maybe worth a new deal?

Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:18 pm  

*1865* wrote:

I'd be disappointed with Talanoa at centre, think his strengths are better suited to the wing.

Shaul
Lancaster
Fonua
Logan
Talanoa

Naughton
Tuimavave

That's based on what we've supposedly signed.

Quite a difference from the back 5 i'd hoped for -

Shaul
Lancaster
Inu
Logan
Vidot

Naughton
Talanoa

I too don't see the need to retain Micheals, but Yeaman does see himself playing in the pack, so maybe worth a new deal?

I don't like Talanoa on the wing, too slow and terrible under the high ball, he isn't a top class centre but makes breaks and with Lancaster backing him up, think he could get a hatful, he would have scored against Wigan. I think he is slightly ahead of Logan who needs more strength, particularly in defence.

Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:24 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

I don't like Talanoa on the wing, too slow and terrible under the high ball, he isn't a top class centre but makes breaks and with Lancaster backing him up, think he could get a hatful, he would have scored against Wigan. I think he is slightly ahead of Logan who needs more strength, particularly in defence.

Defence, especially at centre, is always going to be the one question mark of any young centre. Think with a good off season there's no reason why he can't do a 'Ben Crooks'. As long as he puts the effort in I think it's worth persevering with.

Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:29 pm  

*1865* wrote:

Defence, especially at centre, is always going to be the one question mark of any young centre. Think with a good off season there's no reason why he can't do a 'Ben Crooks'. As long as he puts the effort in I think it's worth persevering with.

I still think he will play plenty of games, any injury to wingers, centres or halfs I'd expect him to be in.

Wasn't convinced about him, but has impressed me again this year.

I really like the look of Bower from the 19s, has all the attributes to be a top centre.

Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:33 pm  

*1865* wrote:

I'd be disappointed with Talanoa at centre, think his strengths are better suited to the wing.

Shaul
Lancaster
Fonua
Logan
Talanoa

Naughton
Tuimavave

That's based on what we've supposedly signed.

Quite a difference from the back 5 i'd hoped for -

Shaul
Lancaster
Inu
Logan
Vidot

Naughton
Talanoa

I too don't see the need to retain Micheals, but Yeaman does see himself playing in the pack, so maybe worth a new deal?

Yeamo is signed on for 2016 on a lesser contract.

Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:38 pm  

easthull fc fan wrote:

Yeamo is signed on for 2016 on a lesser contract.

Which could be 0 on the cap if they use the extra 50k because of his long service.

Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:43 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

Which could be 0 on the cap if they use the extra 50k because of his long service.

Which make him amazing value compared to Washbrook, as an example

Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:43 pm  

easthull fc fan wrote:

Yeamo is signed on for 2016 on a lesser contract.

Yeah I know, I meant Micheals might be worth another year with Yeamo wanting to move in to the pack.

Re: Carlos Tuimavave Signs : Sun Jul 26, 2015 7:44 pm  

Dave K. wrote:

Which could be 0 on the cap if they use the extra 50k because of his long service.

I'd still be surprised if we get value for money.