Probably worse than the ps2 games. Shocking. I want to trade it in, but I doubt I'll get much for it. Can't do anything in the way of moves, tackling is hard to control, the commentary is dull, the players are all the same pace, etc etc.
What I find strange is that despite the vast sales numbers that there'll be, nobody else is interested in taking the contract away from Sidhe. EA Sports have produced some brilliant rugby union games, it'd be amazing if they'd do an RL one.