Scott Yates : Fri Mar 19, 2010 12:19 pm  

one of the worse if not worse fullback i have ever seen. we need a fullback this is our weakest postion. Would never pick Yates again.

Re: Scott Yates : Fri Mar 19, 2010 1:38 pm  

Eye of the viking wrote:

one of the worse if not worse fullback i have ever seen. we need a fullback this is our weakest postion. Would never pick Yates again.

Bit harsh, needs to step up a level though, unfortunately at a lower Champ side he'd have a few more chances and game time you won't get at Widnes unless your performing at the top level! If we had more cover at full back i'd like to see him spend a month or so with a champ one side see i can get his confidence back, just a slight hesitation in big games can make a huge difference unfortunately for Scott yesterday, though chasing back and tackling he did very well and returned it quite solid when had bal in hand.

Re: Scott Yates : Fri Mar 19, 2010 2:49 pm  

J20 wrote:

Bit harsh, needs to step up a level though, unfortunately at a lower Champ side he'd have a few more chances and game time you won't get at Widnes unless your performing at the top level! If we had more cover at full back i'd like to see him spend a month or so with a champ one side see i can get his confidence back, just a slight hesitation in big games can make a huge difference unfortunately for Scott yesterday, though chasing back and tackling he did very well and returned it quite solid when had bal in hand.

I agree mate.I think a loan to a championship 1 side and play regular at fullback may build his confidence.He is very hesitant and that worries me for a fullback.You never see broadbent,royston,donlan hesitant.Yes full backs make mistakes but hesitancey is a bad trait.

Re: Scott Yates : Fri Mar 19, 2010 7:14 pm  

Eye of the viking wrote:

one of the worse if not worse fullback i have ever seen.

Oh come on, really?!

Re: Scott Yates : Fri Mar 19, 2010 10:19 pm  

OFFTHECUFF wrote:

I agree mate.I think a loan to a championship 1 side and play regular at fullback may build his confidence.He is very hesitant and that worries me for a fullback.You never see broadbent,royston,donlan hesitant.Yes full backs make mistakes but hesitancey is a bad trait.

Maybe too much pressure too soon, I have watched him play for a while, he seemed to get a place at full back over Jonny Leather who at the time, I thought was equally as good, I think he went to Blackpool for game time and experience I guess, not sure if he is still there but could have come good I though.

Re: Scott Yates : Sat Mar 20, 2010 12:09 am  

Jonny Leather is at blackpool and doing very well i believe.Maybe Yates is a good player, but not at top end championship, or superleague.Hope he proves me wrong, but i do not think quite good enough to be a top full back at this level.

Re: Scott Yates : Sat Mar 20, 2010 10:57 pm  

like the old song by peter cooke and dudley moore went, "now is the time to say goodbye"

Re: Scott Yates : Sat Mar 20, 2010 11:19 pm  

All very harsh on here. The lad has had good games for us, deserves a little more respect than he is getting. It's true we might have to make a tough decision in regards to him but to call him the worst ever just shows a complete lack of respect, knowledge and tact.

Re: Scott Yates : Sat Mar 20, 2010 11:20 pm  

Javier Mascherano wrote:

like the old song by peter cooke and dudley moore went, "now is the time to say goodbye"

"We are miserable sinners."

Don't finish that one!

Re: Scott Yates : Sat Mar 20, 2010 11:41 pm  

Leather won Champ 1 young player of the season last year, shows how good he went for them!