Carney or Hall : Tue Jun 26, 2018 12:13 pm  

1. We're awaiting any news on Carney after this season
2. We are allegedly/might look at Hall

Aside from 'why not both' which would you prefer?

We might be looking at releasing Carney to get Hall and free up an oversees spot, but personally I would prefer to keep Carney.

Worst case we may not have either.

Re: Carney or Hall : Tue Jun 26, 2018 12:54 pm  

Hall every time, he's miles better at tickling the ivories and he's reet nice to his mam.

Re: Carney or Hall : Tue Jun 26, 2018 1:33 pm  

Much as I like Carney he’s not in the same league as Hall but there’s no chance Hall is coming anyway

Re: Carney or Hall : Tue Jun 26, 2018 7:34 pm  

Roy hall all the way he’s just like Carney big and strong makes good meters but hall can finish try’s where as Carney has struggled abit at finishing compare to other wingers he doesn’t have that acrobatic skills that wingers have these days... not like hall to rovers will happen unless they offer big money but we need the money spending else where I’d like to see how oaks gets on with a few first team games

Re: Carney or Hall : Tue Jun 26, 2018 9:40 pm  

If we're playing fantasy rugby shall we start a thurston or cronk thread too?

Re: Carney or Hall : Tue Jun 26, 2018 9:54 pm  

[quote="Jake the Peg"]If we're playing fantasy rugby shall we start a thurston or cronk thread too?[/quote]



Not so much fantasy rugby as one of them already plays for us

Re: Carney or Hall : Wed Jun 27, 2018 7:01 am  

Davetherobin wrote:

Roy hall all the way he’s just like Carney big and strong makes good meters but hall can finish try’s where as Carney has struggled abit at finishing compare to other wingers he doesn’t have that acrobatic skills that wingers have these days... not like hall to rovers will happen unless they offer big money but we need the money spending else where I’d like to see how oaks gets on with a few first team games

I can see your points. I would add that I have never seen the same sort of fends or tackle busts from Hall as you get from Carney. If Carney has had a shoulder injury since April that might account for the occasional knock on. You're spot on about spectacular dives in the corner though.

Not holding my breath about Hall. If it is all just conjecture, they must throw more effort behind keeping Carney.

Re: Carney or Hall : Wed Jun 27, 2018 9:31 pm  

fun time frankie wrote:

Not so much fantasy rugby as one of them already plays for us

Which one? cronk or thurston?

Re: Carney or Hall : Thu Jun 28, 2018 10:16 pm  

Thought you guys would have moved on from Craig Hall

I can actually see Hall coming to KR next season - Leeds are probably going to re-build after this season and BM has a bad habit of getting rid of all the wrong players at the wrong time as they get a little bit older! Ali Lauititi a prime example when he came to Wakefield.

Ryan will be 31 the back end of this year and has done all there is to do at Leeds and had his testimonial.. He has no desire to ply his trade in Aus and I am sure KR will offer him a better contract than he will be offered by GH.

Re: Carney or Hall : Fri Jun 29, 2018 6:16 am  

homme vaste wrote:

Thought you guys would have moved on from Craig Hall

I can actually see Hall coming to KR next season - Leeds are probably going to re-build after this season and BM has a bad habit of getting rid of all the wrong players at the wrong time as they get a little bit older! Ali Lauititi a prime example when he came to Wakefield.

Ryan will be 31 the back end of this year and has done all there is to do at Leeds and had his testimonial.. He has no desire to ply his trade in Aus and I am sure KR will offer him a better contract than he will be offered by GH.

Its not happening. Rovers have said they've not been in contact with him or his agent and are not interested.