Re: Eden : Mon Jun 12, 2017 10:02 pm  

Jake the Peg wrote:

If the only criteria for MOS is scoring gimme's on the wing for cas then the award is worthless. It's supposed to be the best player who wins it and I fail to see how that could ever be a winger

Gale will obviously win it if Cas see it through...but the point is not that at all.

Re: Eden : Mon Jun 12, 2017 10:31 pm  

Peter Mannion wrote:

Are you seriously saying Naughton or Rawsthorne (or Shaw) would be joint favourite for Man of Steel if they just switched to the Cas left wing...????

He has scored some wonder tries that even the far less athletic Ryan Hall would have no chance with...the combination of Brisbane and Daryl Powell has unlocked all the potential everyone could see. The task for Powell is to get him to carry it on.

What i am saying is that most of Edens tries are walk ins created by Gale and Shenton.its just pass and catch.Put any young wing from most clubs and they would finish the tries just like Eden has.
Diving in the corner and grounding the ball whilst in the air is fairly standard in todays game.

Re: Eden : Wed Jun 14, 2017 11:44 pm  

bonaire wrote:

What i am saying is that most of Edens tries are walk ins created by Gale and Shenton.its just pass and catch.Put any young wing from most clubs and they would finish the tries just like Eden has.
Diving in the corner and grounding the ball whilst in the air is fairly standard in todays game.

Absolute bollox devaluing his achievements because he played for Rovers. He always had talent but suspect attitude. His Brisbane jaunt taught him a shed load and like many cast offs he's found a home at Cas .I keep reading on sharks board he's rocks or diamonds I expect diamonds on Sunday .Fully expect a humbling for the curlys in cup .shame Moors is out but expect a 20 point Cas win ..... (hopefully )

Re: Eden : Thu Jun 15, 2017 9:00 pm  

craig hkr wrote:

Absolute bollox devaluing his achievements because he played for Rovers. He always had talent but suspect attitude. His Brisbane jaunt taught him a shed load and like many cast offs he's found a home at Cas .I keep reading on sharks board he's rocks or diamonds I expect diamonds on Sunday .Fully expect a humbling for the curlys in cup .shame Moors is out but expect a 20 point Cas win ..... (hopefully )

After you tipped wigan and salford to hammer us in the last 2 weeks I'll take solace from your "prediction" (Although it's really you just hoping and praying) of a big cas win

Re: Eden : Thu Jun 15, 2017 10:46 pm  

craig hkr wrote:

Absolute bollox devaluing his achievements because he played for Rovers. He always had talent but suspect attitude. His Brisbane jaunt taught him a shed load and like many cast offs he's found a home at Cas .I keep reading on sharks board he's rocks or diamonds I expect diamonds on Sunday .Fully expect a humbling for the curlys in cup .shame Moors is out but expect a 20 point Cas win ..... (hopefully )

Nothing to do with playing for HKR.
Its a fact most of his tries are walk ins and would be finished by any current HKR wings and even Hull FC reserve wings like Naughton or Rawsthorne
Paul Cooke stated on Radio Humberside earlier this week that most of Edens tries were walk ins.

Re: Eden : Fri Jun 16, 2017 4:26 pm  

Quoting Paul Cooke?Don't recall Solomona try's being devalued last term?Eden looks stronger up top and maybe even a little quicker than when with us.Positionally sound and seems better under high ball.

Re: Eden : Fri Jun 16, 2017 4:34 pm  

Jake the Peg wrote:

After you tipped wigan and salford to hammer us in the last 2 weeks I'll take solace from your "prediction" (Although it's really you just hoping and praying) of a big cas win

Wasn't expecting wigan to win particularly but yea I thought Salford would win.Thankfully I don't bet on results anymore just 1st try as like the value and had fair few doubles and trebles this term.i won't see your game in cup but I expect a fair appraisal on Mr Eden afterwards

Re: Eden : Sun Jun 18, 2017 8:27 am  

Jake the Peg wrote:

If the only criteria for MOS is scoring gimme's on the wing for cas then the award is worthless. It's supposed to be the best player who wins it and I fail to see how that could ever be a winger

There's a lot of things you fail to see jake...Joe Lydon, Martin Offiah and Pat Richards have all won the MOS award in previous years from the wing position. Then again, as your main approach on RL fans is just to get a rise by constantly deriding others posts, I don't expect any else from you. Really poor trolling in its extreme.
Zzzz

Re: Eden : Sun Jun 18, 2017 9:42 am  

spegs wrote:

There's a lot of things you fail to see jake...Joe Lydon, Martin Offiah and Pat Richards have all won the MOS award in previous years from the wing position. Then again, as your main approach on RL fans is just to get a rise by constantly deriding others posts, I don't expect any else from you. Really poor trolling in its extreme.
Zzzz

Let's you back on the Internet have They? Won't last

Re: Eden : Sun Jun 18, 2017 11:19 am  

spegs wrote:

There's a lot of things you fail to see jake...Joe Lydon, Martin Offiah and Pat Richards have all won the MOS award in previous years from the wing position. Then again, as your main approach on RL fans is just to get a rise by constantly deriding others posts, I don't expect any else from you. Really poor trolling in its extreme.
Zzzz

Don't mention facts and actual knowledge of the game, he wont understand