[Mild Rover]

Re: Big Clearout : Thu Oct 11, 2018 12:45 pm  

Rye_Robin wrote:

Wasn't Marsh once touted as the next big thing in Super League? - What happened, where did it all go wrong?

Tbf, 42 first team games for Rovers is more than most youngsters promoted to the fringes of the squad ever make.

Where it goes wrong is potential being overhyped and then excessive disappointment when a high proportion of kids don’t make it in SL. There were frequent calls for Oakes to be given more opportunities this year, until it became clear there’s parts of his game that need work. I hope he makes it, but when I see people talk about him as a future international... well, it’s premature at best.

Marsh is the same generation, give or take, as Logan, Lancaster, HTW, Turgut, Downs, Dean et al. So we’re far from alone in this.

Re: Big Clearout : Thu Oct 11, 2018 5:06 pm  

I would be surprised if TS hasn't already got replacements lined up. I suspect that they will be better players and therefore command higher salaries hence the big clear out. Perhaps some of the players that were being touted throughout the season are back in the frame.

Re: Big Clearout : Thu Oct 11, 2018 6:48 pm  

So is Todd staying then? I see he’s not the clearout list. I’m very observant you see.

Re: Big Clearout : Sun Oct 14, 2018 8:49 pm  

SirStan wrote:

Gone:
Clarkson
Kavanagh
Clavering
Moss
Marsh
Salter
Donaldson
Tickle
Walne

Of those, only Kav deserved a new contract IMO.

I agree. Cutting out the deadwood is a non negotiable if we are to progress. We need 4-5 quality signings now and I don't mean cast offs from other middle eight clubs.

Re: Big Clearout : Mon Oct 15, 2018 7:52 am  

Zook Ema's Hose wrote:

I agree. Cutting out the deadwood is a non negotiable if we are to progress. We need 4-5 quality signings now and I don't mean cast offs from other middle eight clubs.

I agree but we need to find good players but we’re from that’s the problem

[Mild Rover]

Re: Big Clearout : Mon Oct 15, 2018 12:32 pm  

I think ‘deadwood’ is unnecessarily harsh on lads who helped us to promotion and/or SL survival.

That said, we do need to improve to challenge higher up the table. But as a lot of clubs are finding, and Someday notes, quality is hard to find. The number of youngsters coming through and becoming established has been low these last few years. It’s been a long-term problem for us, but it seems to be right across SL now. Add to that, a steady trickle of the best of British heading to the NRL and a choice of reserve graders with the right passport to come the other way, and it is really tough. it’s tough for everyone at least, so that is some consolation.