I'm going to go against the grain and say I haven't given up on Keating, although he has largely been rubbish.
Games three to about eight I thought he showed promise, he has a decent short kicking game somewhere trying to get out, but he severely lacks that yard of pace, or savvy and awareness of where the near defenders are from step to go through the gap that a genuine quality half has to have.
I'm in favour of switching him to nine, but can we all please remember that it's his brother that is/was an NRL hooker.