Are you seriously saying it was JD's hand that made contact with Wellens' face?

No I did'nt say that. I said JD led with the Hand. I think it started near the shoulder area then went up into wellens neck/chin.

But the point of initial contact was JD's forearm with Wellens' face (at no point did it hit the chest and ricochet onto the face). Also, you'll notice that JD's hand is further away from the point of contact than the forearm, hence he led with the forearm and not the hand.

I think we should agree to disagree on this one

And look forward to next Sunday for cracking game.All the best.







P.S



I still think you need a new tele

I agree, I've been trying to convince the wife we need a new tele for the last six months!

Looking forward to Sunday, should be a great game. And whoever wins, I hope we both make the eight, who would have thought it after the relegation game a few years back - just shows how strong both clubs are I feel.

will sherwin be back at last?

i doubt it, i said on another post before we payed hull i think he has put his boots away for the rest of this season.

I doubt it.

He made it into the 19 for Salford so that tends to indicate he's close to fully recovered.

So I wouldn't be surprised if he is back.

I reccon Shifty will make his return and make a HUGE impact on the game!

i hope your right but he wasnt in the 19 for salford, the other two were boyle and ford. it just seems to be dragging on to me and i know they need to get him right before he comes back but there doesnt seem to be any positive coments coming from the club about him which just makes me think he wont be playing any time soon.

TM says in LE that he's ready to go but it will more than likely be the HKR games where he returns.