Quote Fat Boy="Fat Boy"Just watching it back now – the Kylie knock-on decision was farcical but what was not noticed was the Platt voluntary tackle when they regained the ball on their own line.'"
Agree with you on the Leuluai 'knock on' although he did fumble the ball in contact so I can also see where Alibert got a ruling from even though with the benefit of replays I didn't agree with the call.
Was the Platt one on the Bradford line where Webb shakes his head at the play the ball call? Alibert got that one spot on as Webb had instinctively placed both hands on the grounded player effecting the tackle. Realising he wanted Platt to get up he moves his hands away but it was too late.
Quote Fat Boy="Fat Boy"Add the Ah Van knock-on only to recover the ball and get bundled over the in-goal line - Penalty to Bradford????? '"
Yes that was a terrible call. Nothing more to add on that one.
However I was impressed when he gave Leeds the penalty for the Ah Van obstruction (and the lead for the first time) on Jones-Buchanan which I had completely missed the first time around and had called a penalty against Leeds. Hardly a 'home call' decision that one.
