No room for sentiment when picked an all time greats side.

For me neither of the props are in the same world as "Brick with eyes", Darren Britt or Webke

darren britt eh?



yeah sure mate.

I don't see any problem with his team. If everybody picked the best players they'd ever seen, then they'd all have the same names cropping up every week and the feature would soon get very boring.



Rugby League Week have been running this feature for years. It's interesting because of the different names that keep appearing.

yeah most of the times it is the same players.



but some of these choices are a bit weird

His selections.



Shaun Edwards??? (GUFFAAWW)

Hic

Martin dermott







Is this chosen from just players Gregory has played with?

No because he picks Sterling at scrum half,his own position I know,but he also considers Meninga as centre,whom he never played with.

I know.Better than Lewis, Kenny or Myler.

Well how the loving hell does dermott get in the dream team?

his comments on martin dermott :



martin was so instrumental in a lot of the success we had at wigan. he passed the ball from the ground so crisply, which is what every half back wants.



he was a bit of an unsung hero in our wigan team because we had so many star players but he always contributed

Because he was average.

Dermott was the best passer of a ball I've ever seen from acting halfback. So much of Wigans dominance came from his fast, accurate distribution. If yoou get a chance read John Monies book "the Ice Man" and his views of Derms.



On the prop forward he's chosen, I don't think James Graham would have been quite so keen to get at Skerrett or Platt.

Sure - most underrated Aussie in SL - ask Saints fans what they thought of Britt - one of the best ball handling props to emerge in the last 20 years - but then would not expect you to comment - you seem more a Mark Carroll man - one of the softest props ever to come here - he got beat up almost every week and went back to Aus with his tail between his legs - didn't even see the season out.

I'm pretty sure that Boyd had retired by the time Skerrett came on the scene and Tamati was over the hill by then too.



Skerrett won more medals than either Sorensen or Ward and lost nothing ion comparison with them at the time as I remember, they were all good props and all played in the ARL.

What I meant was that Gregory played alongside all of those props at one time or another apart from Sorensen whom he played against numerous times.Same era.(ish)

Platt and Skerrett wiped their s with every front row in England (and a few Aussies) for quite a few years. Gregory has every right to include them.



Dermott was a sensational passer of the ball. As Rogues has said, the best passer from acting half back I've ever seen. His knack of making a half break from nothing and sending someone (normally Edwards) clean away was fantastic. He could also mix it and for his size put in quite a few damaging shots at crucial moments. You might think someone else is better, and that's fair enough, but to call him average displays total ignorance of the hooking role and Derm's abilities.



Am I correct in thinking this is 'Andy Gregory's Dream Team', and not 'Andy Gregory's Best Players of All Time Team'.



There is a difference and I can't help thinking he is in a pretty good position to judge.

Britt was good for us, but IMO, not in the same league as Fairleigh. Fairleigh was a class act, one of the best players of the Super League era, IMO.

and not a loiner to be seen



I wonder why!!!

Exactly. When Ellery did his in Rugby League Week, he picked Phil Larder as the coach. There has to be a personal element in these things or it would run its course very quickly.

Steve Hampson was a great full back but the best one I ever saw was Greg Brentnall.He toured with the 82 kangaroos and was a bit of an unsung hero.I went to a few club games on that tour and saw all the tests on TV and he never put a foot wrong.Always in the right place at the right time,safe under the high ball,solid in defence,the bloke oozed class.Cool as a cucumber,he seemed to have lots of time with the ball and without it.Great full back.

its his dream team.

Why?

Of course there is - it's not an 'all time greats side' after all, it's his 'dream team'.



His personal experience is what counts - as far as he's concerned he'd sooner have Eddie Cunningham alongside him. That's fair enough.