That's nonsense we have the lines of Turgut, Abdul, Fash, Matonga, Litten, Wray, Lane, Brown, Sanderson etc, all those above are equal if not bette that's why the first few are becoming established SL players. I'll also back Hull to do a better job at bringing those players through than Rovers.



Your best young player is Oakes, who you nicked from Wakey.

All you've done there is copy the names in the exact order that the hull kr website published them, that have played a game for hull kr first team in the league below super league. Doesn't necessarily mean they are the best youngsters in hull.



Regards



King James

Well we've released one of our non-fed players. That makes 7 plus Moss who had dispensation due to the Bradford situation. Is that better for you Dave? DGM?



I really don't understand why you are so bothered tbh.

I didn't say I was bothered If you actually read the thread properly I was putting a couple of Rovers fans right regarding the actual rules.

Makes sense.

We know Chris' parents and he's a decent guy doing his best for his family ... playing a sport he loves.

We have had many similar people in the Ttinity shirt over the years... our fans even refer to some of them as legends!



Your post hints at conspiracy and misrepresentation on his part! It was intentionally provocative and unnecessary

Bit rich that Dave considering Abdul was nicked from Rovers. As for the other players you've mentioned....bang average kids.

You haven't released him, it's a loan move so as he is still on your books I'd guess it still counts?



This is a rugby forum for all clubs to discuss things like this, I'm interested in rugby that's why we are discussing it, not sure why that's difficult to understand?

Abdul isn't our best young player to be fair and yes we took him from you, he was at Leeds first though if you want to get technical.



Just want to check I'm correct, apart from Abdul (who is on loan at Rovers) all out other young players are bang average and yours are brilliant, if you think this you have seen the likes of Litten or Brown.



I've heard the same thing from Rovers fans for years, but I've only seen Taylor and Wilkin come through your system to make a big impact of the game and both quickly moved to bigger clubs.



Having watched a lot of the academy and young players at both clubs, there are some with great potentialat both clubs, let's just how each clubs develops them.

Who's gone?

Considering you've slated Rovers for using too many overseas players, you really don't understand the rules do you. If he is no longer at Hull KR then how can he be counted on the non-fed list? We only have 7 players classed as non-fed who can play for us the for rest of the season so why would he still count? You could have 15 non-fed on your books but if only 7 are registered to play then you aren't breaking any rules.

Ahh yes, this brings back memories of the Dobson/Mason fiasco. Another example of Rovers bending the Non-Fed/Quota rules.

Perfectly within the rules. Nothing to see here

To be fair I think we're both rubbish at bringing young kids through, if you look how many made the England squad in the last few years and its pretty poor. Wilkin, Taylor, Yeaman and Hodgson are the only ones I can think of and Taylor is far from a regular.



Hulls development policy over recent years has gone backwards seemingly preferring to buy in then develop, one thing our stint in the championship has done is allow us to blood a lot of young kids

Kalifa Faifai Loa is heading to the UK apparently. Anyone any ideas which club will be his destination?

Now or for next season?

This year apparently.

Interesting. Cas have just lost Eden for the year?



Usually would think of clubs around the middle 8's trying to boost chances of staying up or promotion ...



Hull KR have got Masoe so haven't got room now I believe, not sure Fax or Fev would bother, London?



Wire recently signed some backs, Widnes, Leigh or Catalans maybe?

Sid Domic/Mathew Head fiasco..Selective memory again. Feel free to feel humbled

Quote craig hkr="craig hkr"Sid Domic/Mathew Head fiasco..Selective memory again. Feel free to feel humbled'" That wasn't a fiasco . One player was released and another brought in. Quite simple really. George Riley summarises the Dobson/Mason situation quite well, branding it "ridiculous": www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/georgeriley/ ... on_sa.html Stay humble.

Quote craig hkr="craig hkr"Sid Domic/Mathew Head fiasco..Selective memory again. Feel free to feel humbled'" That wasn't a fiasco . One player was released and another brought in. Quite simple really. George Riley summarises the Dobson/Mason situation quite well, branding it "ridiculous": www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/georgeriley/ ... on_sa.html Stay humble.

Brad Dwyer to Leeds

Adam Walker from Saints to Trinity on a 2 1/2 year deal would go under moves in 2017.

Quote DGM="DGM"That wasn't a fiasco . One player was released and another brought in. Quite simple really. George Riley summarises the Dobson/Mason situation quite well, branding it "ridiculous": www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/georgeriley/ ... on_sa.html Stay humble.'" Weekends here again. Hope you earnt a few quid?

Quote DGM="DGM"That wasn't a fiasco . One player was released and another brought in. Quite simple really. George Riley summarises the Dobson/Mason situation quite well, branding it "ridiculous": www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/georgeriley/ ... on_sa.html Stay humble.'" Weekends here again. Hope you earnt a few quid?

Huddersfield, apparently.

Can't be too bad as we have sent out 5/6 of our young players on loan including one to Rovers, so Sheens obviously doesn't agree with Hessle Rover assessment of our bang average young players.