Locky for Kirke?

I rekon Richards is a better all round player than Donald so would put him in.



Roberts from his NRL days last year is better than Hall, so far this year he has been pretty good.



Carmont is in there for any of your centres.



Feka is in for anyone other than Peacock.



Hock in for any of your second rowers.



There are afew ones that are debateable as well-

Ablett- Hanson or Lockers

Diskin- Riddell (from his NRL form)



The big difference between us and you is your FB and half-back combo.

Webb

Donald

Smith

Carmont

Richards

McGuire

Burrow

Fielden(reckon he's better then Leuluai tbh even at his current lower level)

Diskin

Peacock

JJB

Hock

Sinfield



subs

Paleaaesina

K Leuluai

Lauititi

T Leuluai



We'd get 6 in a combined 17 imo(from the players that are fit). I'd have put O'Loughlin in for Sinfield aswell but Sinfield brings alot to the Leeds team and he works well with McGuire and Burrow.

Cameron Phelps is fit again but Noble has not named him in the 19.



Fair play





[size=59Take note I am praising Brian Noble[/size

Says who? He said 2 weeks in the SS Bar last week.

[urlhttp://www.wigantoday.net/warriors/Phelps-returns-from-injury.5058872.jp[/url

Your all choosing a team of losers then?

If people are saying Lockers instead of any of the Leeds team, I would much rather have J Tomkins instead of him.

senior is still the best defencive centre in the league and is still a better centre than owt you lot have got. but thats just my opinion.



carmont looks great a times but his defence is very poor at times.

if you think this is the big difference between our teams then its show you know jack about the game.



its so much more than what you have said

But Senior is not in the team this week!

I would take Leuluai over Feka, he offers only just less impact than Feka but for much longer periods.

I could be on longer than feka but still do f*ck all. He would be even more destructive in your team - imagine the breaks he would set up for mcguire. Just a shame we havent seen sense to have someone running with him every time to take the offload yet.

As long as Leeds play Ablett im happy, ive more skill in my left testicle.

African Bum Disease?

You should be playing then, because the Wigan team certainly hasn't. He would walk into your team over any of them.

Ahead of who?

No he wouldn't.



Although I do think he has serious potential, he needs to lose about 2 stone, and improve his ball retention.

Have a look at this then.

[urlhttp://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1=2008&hp1=1135&hs2=2008&hp2=1212&stat=tries&season=2008[/url





Leuluai comes nowhere near Feka in any facet of the game.

We are talking about Ablett here. Have you got confused? How the hell could he lose 2 stone? He is a ball playing back rower, previously a stand off, who can also play centre. He is the perfect build and weight for that role.



Like I said he would walk into your team in the back row. Hell he is better than your centres for that position.

*ahem* Ahead of who?

Hansen, Tomkins, Prescott, Coley, who ever you want in there. Until Hock has proven his discipline is not just temporarily held in, I would have him before him too.

Maybe 2 stone is excessive but he is overweight IMO, and he does look like he carries his weight that slow, he is very slow off the mark IMO, but he is quick when he gets going.



I'm a Leeds fan by the way.

Hahahaha, So you've picked two props, when you said 2nd row. And to even suggest that he is better than Hansen, Tomkins and Hock!!! LOL.



Those 3 would excell in a world class side like yours, Ablett at wigan wouldnt do anything. He is average in a class team.

Hansen and Tomkins, don't be stupid.



Prescott and Coley are primarily front rowers.



And Hock? Well you've lost the plot.